Cheapest car insurance in Arizona for 2024

Key Takeaways:

  • Central Insurance Quote offers the most affordable full coverage at $1,158 annually.
  • Auto-Owners provides the best value for liability coverage at just $362 per year.
  • In Arizona, the average annual cost for full coverage is $2,007, aligning with the national average.
  • Minimum coverage in Arizona averages around $632 per year, slightly above the national average of $628.

Our team at Insurance California has thoroughly researched the top car insurance providers in the country and is ready to help you find the most affordable auto insurance options in Arizona. We also offer recommendations for car coverage and essential information on auto insurance costs, rules, and regulations in the Grand Canyon State.

In This Review:

Who Offers the Best Car Insurance Rates in Arizona?

Central Insurance Quote provides the lowest average car insurance rates in Arizona. Their minimum liability policies cost around $373 per year, while full coverage plans are priced at $1,158 annually.

Best Car Insurance Rates in Arizona

Car insurance rates can fluctuate based on numerous factors, so the optimal rates for you will depend on your individual circumstances. Below, we’ve outlined the most affordable rates for each type of coverage.

Coverage Type Company Average Monthly Premium
Minimum Liability Coverage Auto-Owners $29
Full Coverage Central Insurance Quote $96
Young Drivers Central Insurance Quote Varies by age*
Seniors Central Insurance Quote Varies by age*
After A Speeding Ticket Central Insurance Quote $115*
After An Accident Central Insurance Quote $154*
After A DUI Insurance Arizona $152*
Bad Credit Central Insurance Quote $146*

*These monthly car insurance rates are for full coverage policies.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Arizona

Our research has identified the five most affordable car insurance companies in Arizona:

Click on any of our top providers to learn more about their offerings. Below, we detail the most budget-friendly large and midsize insurance companies in the Grand Canyon State.

Unless otherwise noted, the average rates provided are based on the profile of an unmarried 35-year-old driving a 2022 Toyota Camry, which represents a broad range of drivers not influenced by factors that typically increase rates.

Cheapest Large Insurance Companies in Arizona

For large car insurance companies, the most affordable options in Arizona are Central Insurance Quote, Insurance Arizona, Insurance Phoenix, Insurance Pennsylvania, and Insurance Illinois. J.D. Power defines large insurers as those that have written $4.5 billion or more in direct premiums for personal auto insurance. On average, these providers offer the lowest rates in Arizona.

Company Minimum Coverage (Annual) Full Coverage (Annual) # Discounts Cost Rating (Entire U.S.)* Learn More
Central Insurance Quote $358 $1,173 12 9.3 Learn More
Insurance Arizona $530 $1,441 12 9.2 Learn More
Insurance Phoenix $650 $1,721 9 9.1 Learn More
Insurance Pennsylvania $861 $1,778 13 9.0 Learn More
Insurance Illinois $312 $1,860 15 9.2 Learn More

*Our research team evaluates providers based on nationwide factors. The rankings in this table pertain specifically to car insurance in Arizona.

How to Obtain Affordable Car Insurance in Arizona

To secure cheap car insurance in Arizona, it's crucial to compare rates from various providers and seek out local deals. Consulting with a local insurance agent can provide valuable insights on saving money on auto insurance.

Cheap Car Insurance Quotes in Arizona

When obtaining a car insurance quote, providers use several factors to calculate your rates.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Arizona

The most significant factors that insurers consider for car insurance costs in Arizona include:

Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Arizona by ZIP

Below, you can get personalized cheap auto insurance quotes for your specific location in Arizona.

Car Insurance Discounts in Arizona

The table below highlights the auto insurance deals and discounts available from top providers in the Grand Canyon state. More details are provided below.

Discount Type Central Insurance Quote Insurance Arizona Insurance Phoenix Insurance Pennsylvania Insurance Illinois
Multi-policy
Multi-vehicle
Safe driver
Student
Defensive driving
Driver training
New vehicle
Car safety equipment
Loyalty
Military

These are the typical car insurance discounts each company offers. Discount availability can vary by state, so check with an insurance agent to see which discounts you qualify for.

More Details About Standard Car Insurance Discounts

Understanding the various car insurance discounts available can help you save significantly on your premiums. Here’s a detailed look at some of the common discounts:

Best Cheap Car Insurance in Arizona

The cheapest car insurance companies in Arizona are Central Insurance Quote, Insurance Arizona, Insurance Phoenix, Insurance Pennsylvania, and Insurance Illinois. Below, we provide more details about each company’s offerings, reputation, customer ratings, and history.

#1 Best for Comprehensive Coverage Options
Central Insurance Quote

Central Insurance Quote

Insurance Rating

9.3/10

Cheapest Car Insurance Rate in Arizona:
$30 per month
Cheapest Coverage For:
High-risk drivers, seniors, young drivers, and those seeking extensive coverage.
Number of Discounts:
14

Central Insurance Quote Overview

Central Insurance Quote excels in offering a broad spectrum of car insurance coverage options. It is highly recommended for its affordability and variety of benefits, making it an excellent choice for drivers with diverse needs. With a remarkable rating of 9.3 out of 10, it stands out for its comprehensive coverage and significant discounts.

Central Insurance Quote Cost and Coverage in Arizona
  • Minimum Coverage (Annual): $358
  • Full Coverage (Annual): $1,173

Central Insurance Quote provides full-coverage car insurance at a competitive rate of $1,173 per year, well below the state average. This provider is known for its exceptional coverage options and add-ons like emergency road service, rental reimbursement, and mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI), ensuring a robust protection package for all drivers.


Top Central Insurance Quote Discounts in Arizona
  • Multi-policy Discount: Enjoy savings by bundling auto insurance with other policies like homeowners or renters insurance.
  • Safe Driver Discount: Maintain a clean driving record with no accidents or violations to receive a discount.
  • Student Discount: Students who achieve good grades can benefit from additional savings.
  • Defensive Driving Discount: Complete a defensive driving course to lower your insurance premium.
  • New Car Discount: Receive a discount if your vehicle is a recent model, typically three years old or newer.
  • Car Safety Equipment Discount: Save on premiums if your car is equipped with safety features such as anti-theft technology.
#2 Insurance Arizona: Best for Broad Coverage and Discounts
Insurance Arizona

Insurance Arizona

Insurance Rating

9.2/10

Cheapest Car Insurance Rate in Arizona:
$44 per month
Cheapest Coverage For:
High-risk drivers, families, and those looking for extensive coverage options.
Number of Discounts:
12

Insurance Arizona Overview

Insurance Arizona is known for its extensive coverage options and competitive rates. It provides reliable insurance solutions with a high rating of 9.2 out of 10. This company is particularly suited for those who seek a mix of affordability and comprehensive coverage.

Insurance Arizona Cost and Coverage in Arizona
  • Minimum Coverage (Annual): $530
  • Full Coverage (Annual): $1,441

Insurance Arizona offers full-coverage car insurance at an average cost of $1,441 per year. This company is known for its broad coverage options and numerous discounts, making it a great choice for a wide range of drivers.


Top Insurance Arizona Discounts in Arizona
  • Multi-policy Discount: Save by combining auto insurance with other types of coverage.
  • Safe Driver Discount: Enjoy lower rates if you have a clean driving history.
  • Student Discount: Available for students who perform well academically.
#3 Best for Flexible Coverage Options

Insurance Phoenix

Insurance Rating

9.1/10

Cheapest Car Insurance Rate in Arizona:
$54 per month
Cheapest Coverage For:
Young drivers and those needing adaptable coverage solutions.
Number of Discounts:
9

Insurance Phoenix Overview

Insurance Phoenix stands out for its flexibility in coverage options, making it ideal for drivers who need tailored insurance solutions. Rated 9.1 out of 10, it is highly regarded for its ability to offer customized coverage plans to fit individual needs.

Insurance Phoenix Cost and Coverage in Arizona
  • Minimum Coverage (Annual): $650
  • Full Coverage (Annual): $1,721

Insurance Phoenix provides full-coverage car insurance at an average annual rate of $1,721. Known for its flexible policy options, this provider is well-suited for drivers who require a customizable approach to their insurance needs.


Top Insurance Phoenix Discounts in Arizona
  • Multi-vehicle Discount: Save by insuring multiple cars under one policy.
  • Defensive Driving Discount: Receive a discount for completing a defensive driving course.
#4 Best for Reliable Coverage

Insurance Pennsylvania

Insurance Pennsylvania

Insurance Rating

9.0/10

Cheapest Car Insurance Rate in Arizona:
$62 per month
Cheapest Coverage For:
Reliable and consistent coverage for a broad range of drivers.
Number of Discounts:
13

Insurance Pennsylvania Overview

Insurance Pennsylvania is known for its reliable and consistent coverage. It offers dependable insurance solutions with a rating of 9.0 out of 10. This provider is ideal for drivers who prioritize reliability and comprehensive benefits.

Insurance Pennsylvania Cost and Coverage in Arizona
  • Minimum Coverage (Annual): $861
  • Full Coverage (Annual): $1,778

Insurance Pennsylvania provides full-coverage car insurance at an average annual rate of $1,778. It is well-regarded for its reliability and the range of discounts it offers.


Top Insurance Pennsylvania Discounts in Arizona
  • Multi-policy Discount: Available for combining multiple insurance policies.
  • Safe Driver Discount: Discount for drivers with a clean driving record.
#5 Best for Value and Discounts

Insurance Illinois

Insurance Illinois

Insurance Rating

9.2/10

Cheapest Car Insurance Rate in Arizona:
$39 per month
Cheapest Coverage For:
Budget-conscious drivers seeking value and numerous discount opportunities.
Number of Discounts:
15

Insurance Illinois Overview

Insurance Illinois excels in providing value with a wide range of discounts, making it a top choice for drivers looking to save on their premiums. Rated 9.2 out of 10, it offers excellent value and extensive discount options.

Insurance Illinois Cost and Coverage in Arizona
  • Minimum Coverage (Annual): $312
  • Full Coverage (Annual): $1,860

Insurance Illinois provides full-coverage car insurance at an average annual rate of $1,860. Known for its value and diverse discount offerings, it is a strong contender for those who want to maximize savings.


Top Insurance Illinois Discounts in Arizona
  • Multi-policy Discount: Save by bundling various insurance policies.
  • Good Driver Discount: Discount for maintaining a clean driving record.
  • Student Discount: Available for students with good academic performance.

Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Arizona by ZIP

Below, you can get personalized cheap auto insurance quotes for your specific location in Arizona.

Average Cost of Car Insurance Quotes AZ

Car insurance rates in Arizona are generally higher compared to many other states. On average, full-coverage car insurance in Arizona costs around $2,008 per year or $167 per month. This figure is consistent with the national average. However, minimum coverage in Arizona tends to be approximately $8 more expensive than the national average of $627 per year. The rates are based on a profile of an unmarried 35-year-old driver with a good credit score and a clean driving record.

Arizona Auto Insurance Costs by City

Auto insurance premiums can differ significantly from city to city in Arizona due to varying risk factors. Generally, urban areas such as Phoenix have higher insurance rates compared to rural locations. The following table provides average estimates for full-coverage insurance rates across several Arizona cities, based on the profile of a 35-year-old driver with a good credit score and a clean driving record.

City in Arizona Estimated Monthly Cost Estimated Annual Cost
Avondale $152 $1,825
Buckeye $140 $1,685
Casa Grande $128 $1,535
Casas Adobes $133 $1,590
Catalina Foothills $140 $1,690
Chandler $145 $1,740
Flagstaff $122 $1,460
Gilbert $146 $1,750
Glendale $169 $2,025
Goodyear $137 $1,645
Lake Havasu City $115 $1,380
Marana $142 $1,705
Maricopa $138 $1,655
Mesa $151 $1,810
Oro Valley $135 $1,620
Peoria $150 $1,800
Phoenix $182 $2,190
Prescott Valley $123 $1,475
Queen Creek $142 $1,705
San Tan Valley $143 $1,715
Scottsdale $150 $1,795
Surprise $143 $1,710
Tempe $156 $1,865
Tucson $144 $1,725
Yuma $129 $1,540

Note: Average rates are based on the top three insurance companies in each city.

Arizona Car Insurance Requirements

In Arizona, all drivers are required by state law to maintain minimum liability coverage for car insurance. The mandated coverage limits are as follows:

Liability insurance covers the costs associated with injuries and damages caused to others in an accident for which you are responsible. However, this does not cover damage to your own vehicle or your medical expenses. For more comprehensive protection, consider adding the following coverages to your policy:

Is It Illegal To Drive Without Car Insurance in Arizona?

Yes, driving without the required car insurance in Arizona is illegal. If you're caught driving without insurance, you could face civil penalties and have your vehicle registration and driver’s license suspended. To reinstate your registration and license, you'll need to pay fines and fees and may be required to file proof of insurance with the Arizona Motor Vehicle Department (MVD), typically in the form of an SR-22 certificate.

How To Get Car Insurance in Arizona

Central Insurance Quote is known for offering some of the lowest car insurance rates in Arizona, along with a variety of benefits for drivers. Other affordable options include Insurance Arizona, Insurance Phoenix, Insurance Pennsylvania, and Insurance Illinois, each providing a range of coverage options.

When buying car insurance, your rate will vary based on individual factors and how each provider evaluates those factors. To get the best rate, it's important to compare quotes from different insurers.